In a small community like ours, avoiding accountability is almost impossible, as it should be! We know one another, work together, serve on the same committees, and stand in the same grocery-store line. Even if we would rather not be friends with someone, we’re likely to run into them somewhere before the week is out.
When something goes wrong in a rural community, the rumors and misinformation can spread quickly. A careless, mean-spirited remark at a meeting can linger for days. A promise a local organization makes can affect volunteers, families, and neighbours. A disagreement between two individuals can have the power to divide a committee—or even the town. But it doesn’t have to.
This is why accountability matters. It helps us address harm before resentment takes root and becomes part of the local landscape.
It goes without saying that we all make mistakes. We say things we wish we hadn’t. It helps to remember that when it’s time to address these foibles, we are all subject to the same pressures. Judging others based solely on their perspectives doesn’t help us move toward a civil solution.
Accountability begins with acknowledging exactly what happened. This sounds simple, yet it is often where the process stalls. We may minimize the problem, blame someone else, or insist that our intentions were good.
Our intentions matter, but they don’t erase the effect of what we said or did. We may not have intended to embarrass someone, exclude a neighbour, or create trouble for a volunteer. Yet that may still have been the result. Accountability asks us to look at both what we meant and what actually happened.
The next step is to identify our role and take responsibility for seeing it through to resolution. Most disagreements are not as tidy as we would like. One person may have spoken carelessly, while another made an unfair assumption. A committee may have failed to communicate clearly, while someone affected by its decision reacted angrily.
Taking responsibility does not mean accepting blame for everything. What it does mean, however, is owning what belongs to us without pawning any of it off on someone else. We too often misconstrue this as a sign of weakness when, in fact, it is quite the opposite. It shows we are grown-ups – albeit grown-ups who occasionally need reminding.
Listening is an essential part of accountability. Before we explain ourselves, we need to understand how the other person experienced what happened. This requires patience, pausing, and taking a slow, deep breath, especially when we disagree with what we hear.
Listening means allowing another person’s experience to coexist with ours. Both versions can be true at the same time. Two people can remember the same conversation differently, which can inadvertently leave someone feeling hurt and damage our trust.
I remember playing the telephone game with my young classmates. Inexplicably, words and their meanings morph into something that bears no resemblance to the original idea. We all found it hilarious at the time. Yet, this human foible reminds us to listen more closely when others speak.
When it’s time to apologize, it’s critical to be clear about what we are apologizing for and to show remorse for the pain and suffering we have caused. Instead of skirting the issue with, “I am sorry you felt that way,” say, “I am sorry I hurt you,” and keep responsibility where it belongs: with the perpetrator.
Apologizing and taking responsibility aren’t easy for some people. Those individuals may benefit from a clearer understanding of how their words and actions affect others. Compassion, as difficult as it may be to muster in the moment, can help diffuse tensions and make repair possible.
Sometimes repair means correcting misinformation, replacing something damaged, or keeping a neglected promise. It likely will mean changing how we do things in the future.
We cannot insist that someone forgive us on our preferred schedule. Trust is not restored simply because we are tired of discussing the matter. It returns when our actions show that we understand what went wrong and have changed our behaviour.
Accountability also requires self-compassion. If admitting a single mistake leads us to believe we are terrible people, we will naturally want to defend ourselves. But there is a great difference between saying, “I did something wrong,” and saying, “Everything about me is wrong.”
Self-compassion gives us the courage to face the truth. It does not excuse poor behaviour. It helps us learn from it without getting mired in shame.
This process may matter even more in small communities, where holding grudges can cause unnecessary stress and lasting harm. After all, as members of our communities, we rely on one another during natural disasters, family emergencies, and community crises. This offers a reasonable path forward by allowing us to apply what we have learned to our future behavior.
Jay Remer was raised in the United States and emigrated to Canada roughly 30 years ago. Since then, I have been involved in the writers’ community and the hospitality industry. I live in Saint Andrews, NB, and look forward to the day when healthy, civil debates bear more compassionate outcomes. Please feel free to send your questions: jayremer@chco.tv
